MIRROR OF HER DREAMS and A MAN RIDES THROUGH, by Stephen Donaldson
Genre: Fantasy
Availability: IP and also widely available in used bookstores.
Special Notes: *MC
Rating:
Review: A magnificent duology that reads like an adult fairytale--intellectual, romantic, fantastic, mysterious, and inspiring on a multiple set of levels. Donaldson's books have a heavy feminist message, which is refreshing to see coming from a male author. There isn't much of a Phantom connection in these books at all, but Geraden, one of the 2 main characters, is extremely reminiscent of the young Michael Crawford. The cover of my paperback of Mirror even looks like him! In A Man Rides Through, the matching qualities fade a bit, but by then you're so hooked on the books that you'll have to read through both.
Availability: IP, try ordering a copy from your bookstore.
Special Notes: *MC
Rating:
Review: Dragonsbane is a light fantasy that inverts most fairy-tale stereotypes. It's the wise, middle-aged, unbeautiful witch who fights for good against a beautiful young enchantress; Prince Charming is a bumbling dear by the name of Gareth. (The gawky Gareth being a dead ringer for Michael Crawford's youthful comedic characters.) It's an endearing read, but I admit the Michael fan in me wants to see more of Gareth in it! :0
Special Notes: *MC ("A Funny Thing Happened..." tribute)
Rating:
Review: We have another sweet-and-bumbling Michael Crawford portrayal in this novel, which is really more a try at historical fiction than fantasy. (It's by a fantasy author, hence it landed here in my classification scheme.) No real Phantom story, just the efforts of our hero to reclaim his kidnapped beloved in the midst of ancient Rome's religious clashes. Search the Seven Hills is a nice tribute to Michael, but slow to grab the reader's eye and interest.
"THE PHANTOM OF THE SPACE OPERA," a short story in The Ultimate Alien, edited by Byron Preiss, John Betancourt, and
Keith R.A. DeCandido, illustrated by Christopher H. Bing.
Genre: Fantasy
Availability: IP. It's
a Dell Trade Paperback, published by Dell Publishing, a division of
Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group, Inc., 1540 Broadway, New York,
NY 10036, copyright 1995.
Availability: IP; American hardback edition now out.
Special Notes: *MC ("Some Mothers Do 'Have Em" tribute). Characters in book a carry-over from other Pratchett Books, like Wyrd Sisters.
Rating:
Review: Maskerade, brings together Pratchett's fantasy realm of his "Discworld" series with a certain well-known story about a masked man. The result is an uproarious, unique, and absolutely enjoyable romp through the Phantom's Opera.
Previous Pratchett fans will recognize the pillars of the tale, with whom the story opens, but no prior Pratchett experience is necessary to be charmed by the characters. Granny Weatherwax and the irrepressible Nanny Ogg, resident witches of Lancre, are in need of a third witch to round out their coven. The girl they have in mind has left her hometown and gone to work in the city of Ank-Morpork, so Granny and Nanny decide to pay a visit to Agnes and take care of some other business in the city. But, when they arrive, the ladies discover that their candidate, Agnes, is working at the Ank-Morpork Opera. And that Opera, it would appear, has a Ghost and a stream of murders under its roof. It's up to our friends Nanny and Granny to go behind the mask and discover who is the Phantom of this Opera.
The characters of Maskerade are memorable and extremely amusing. For all their witchcraft, the hilariously drawn characters of Nanny and Granny will no doubt remind readers of someone in their pasts. Greebo, Nanny's cat, is a one-eyed, malevolent, randy, and mangy source of tears-in-your-eyes-laughter. Agnes, the aspiring (and overweight) soprano from Lancre, adds a depth of reality to this story; as the real heroine of the book, it is through her eyes that Pratchett slips in his own sharp commentary on a society preferring beauty over intelligence and undeniable talent. Phantom fans may look askance at first at the air-headed character of Christine here, but even in the flights of her ditziness, Pratchett makes her wickedly funny. For fans of Michael Crawford, the bumbling, beret-sporting character of Walter Plinge is an obvious and winsome tribute to Crawford's France Spencer from the "Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em" series; for general fans of Andrew Lloyd Webber, Pratchett does not miss his opportunity to lay some outrageously funny tributes at the composer's feet.
There's little not to love about Maskerade. This fantasy farce offers a sly and persistent adult wit to its readers. Moreover, the wildly shifting plotline is completely unpredictable, leaving the reader uncertain about the identity of the Phantom until the final pages. On the downside, for Phantom fans, the nature of Pratchett's writing does mean that the romantic nature of the myth is downplayed in favor of the humorous possibilities. Also, the characters sometimes display a sterling sense of morality reminiscent of old childhood cartoons. But that sense of the old-fashioned fairy tale just makes Maskeradeall the more endearing. At the close of the book, this unique novel will win a singular place in the hearts of readers and Phantom fans both.